The ambience was on the better side of buffet restaurants. The service was good, very attentive and helpful. The food was above average for a buffet. Some items suffered from long-term exposure like the egg rolls and the fried dumplings were tasteless and dry. The sushi was OK Plentiful on the green seaweed not crazy about the orange gari. I prefer the undyed ginger. for the money it was a great deal.

Food is good with lots of choices. It is self service but friendly staff to help if needed. Prices moderate and nice atmosphere. We are new to the area and have eaten there twice. Both times had a great experience!

Don't let the nickname "shitty buffet" fool you--this is a mighty fine dining experience. Stuff yourself with some good ol greasy Chinese food, have some fresh Mongolian grill to top it off, maybe a touch of sushi, and then eat all the fruit you can to make sure you aren't feeling too weary by the end. If you want an Asian buffet, this is the spot in Treasure Valley. 15$ to be stuffed all day, doesn't get better than that

When choosing to come here, I took my boy's Daym Drops advice to come to the buffet right when they open. The food you'll fine is your typical buffet food. They do have a Mongolian grill and a full sushi bar which I may add it's very tasty and popular. The food itself was very good, it tasted fresh as they had just opened. My only complaint would be the cream cheese Rangoons I felt like there was too much shell and not enough filling. The staff is very welcoming, we got we warm greeting as we walked in the door. We were acknowledge and were told it would be just a moment as the hostess was sitting a family down. To me this is where the ball was dropped a little as we got sat in a back room and sorta felt like we were forgotten as my drink was empty and had to flag out waitress down to get a refill. The dining room and food station was clean and that's what I like to see. People that take pride in where they work and it makes people feel welcomed. Besides the drink issue which I felt hindered City Buffet from a perfect score. I have nothing bad to say.

Great variety & price is reasonable Give it a try if you're looking for an Asian Buffet with plenty of choices

When visiting our step-daughter, she recommended this buffet as a good place to go while her kids (who don't eat much) were in school. So we came, just the three, and were free to peruse a huge variety of both Asian and American foods. The staff did a great job of keeping the trays full and hot, and the quality of the items was very good for buffet food. The sushi was also hand made right at the counter, and very nicely done. Service was good, as we had people come to take empty plates or refill our water. Friendly and efficient.

Visiting Caldwell for a family reunion, we needed a place to accommodate 25 people. Called several places but no one could help. I called City Buffet of course! They had room for us! Very nice staff! And a large selection of Good Food! Even our picky eaters found something they liked!